Understanding the Science Behind Face Masks and Their Efficacy
Written on
Chapter 1: The Misconceptions Surrounding Face Masks
The debate over the effectiveness of face masks has been rife with misinformation. Many have claimed that masks "don't work," yet robust evidence backing this assertion is notably absent.
As a note from the author, this article was initially penned in March 2020, a time when wearing masks was often stigmatized in the U.S. I aimed to highlight the challenges faced by individuals like a doctor ridiculed for donning a mask, a hospital employee barred from wearing one, and an airline worker with a compromised immune system who was also prohibited from using masks while on duty.
Since its initial release, this article has been referenced by prominent outlets such as New York Magazine and CNN. Rather than revise it in light of evolving discussions, I urge readers to remember its original purpose: advocating for the right to wear a mask. While much of the content remains intact, any new information is marked with an asterisk (*). I wish everyone strength in the coming months.
As we prepare to return to our routines, it’s crucial to adopt measures to curb the spread of the coronavirus. This necessitates an urgent discussion regarding COVID-19 safety protocols.
Initially, media outlets and government bodies assured the public that masks were ineffective and might even elevate the risk of infection. Such claims were so prevalent that some airlines and businesses prohibited their staff from wearing masks, a decision that could have dire consequences.
Despite the claims that masks are ineffective, substantial evidence to support this stance is lacking. Yes, projections regarding COVID-19 fatalities are concerning, yet we can still overcome this challenge if we equip ourselves with accurate information to mitigate the risk of infection.
Masks, no evidence they work - YouTube
This video examines the claims regarding mask efficacy and explores the lack of evidence supporting the notion that they are ineffective in preventing the spread of COVID-19.
What Relevant Research Exists?
COVID-19, caused by the SARS-CoV-2 virus, is relatively new, compelling scientists to gather data to understand its transmission better. Due to this limited data, researchers often look to similar diseases for insights.
Although COVID-19 is a novel illness, its causative agent is closely linked to the SARS virus from the epidemic 17 years ago. Initial opinions regarding masks were likely influenced more by influenza research than by COVID-19 data.
Can Masks Protect Against SARS?
Research from the SARS outbreak indicates that face masks were the most consistently effective method for minimizing the risk of contracting and spreading the virus. A Cochrane Review found that out of seven studies, six demonstrated significant protection from both surgical and N95 masks. Hand hygiene was also shown to be effective, with four out of seven studies supporting this in a multivariate analysis.
One study in Beijing, tracking community transmission, noted that consistent mask usage correlated with a 70% decrease in the likelihood of contracting SARS. Interestingly, the majority of the population utilized simple surgical masks rather than N95 respirators.
This evidence may explain why several countries encourage or mandate public mask usage and why the CDC suggests wearing masks around infected individuals.
It’s crucial to highlight the extreme risk faced by healthcare workers due to the current shortage of masks. Furthermore, proper mask usage is essential, as wearing them correctly and consistently maximizes their protective benefits.
Can Masks Guard Against Influenza?
Generally, studies on influenza align with the current emphasis on hand hygiene. While many findings support the efficacy of masks against influenza, some research presents mixed results.
One study indicated that children improperly using masks had a slightly higher infection rate of H1N1. In contrast, those using masks correctly halved their infection risk, suggesting the need for education on proper mask techniques.
Another frequently cited review warns that masks might increase transmission risk, yet it references a WHO info sheet rather than empirical research to substantiate this claim.
Are Viruses Small Enough to Pass Through Masks?
While COVID-19 particles, at around 100 nanometers in size, can potentially pass through face masks, the likelihood of transmission is more complex. When a person coughs, the droplets can range from 8,000 to 100,000 nanometers in diameter. Smaller aerosols comprise a mere fraction of the total liquid expelled.
Recent research indicates that surgical masks can significantly diminish the number of exhaled viruses in both large droplets and aerosols.
Even though face masks provide partial protection from airborne viruses, other crucial preventive measures like regular handwashing remain vital.
COVID-19 & Mask Myths DEBUNKED! - YouTube
This video addresses common misconceptions about masks and emphasizes the importance of wearing them to reduce COVID-19 transmission.
Are N95 Respirators More Efficient Than Surgical Masks?
The effectiveness of N95 masks compared to surgical masks is still under debate. N95 respirators may offer superior protection due to their ability to filter smaller particles and provide a tighter fit. However, they are less comfortable, often misused, and removed more frequently than surgical masks.
Theoretically, N95 masks are preferable for caregivers of COVID-19 patients. However, data regarding influenza shows minimal differences in effectiveness between the two types of masks, which is likely why public health authorities do not recommend widespread N95 usage.
What About Cloth Masks?
Due to the scarcity of surgical and N95 masks, many have turned to homemade fabric masks. While research on fabric masks is limited, they may provide comparable protection to some surgical masks.
One study found that healthcare workers using surgical masks had lower illness rates than those using cloth masks. However, the study has limitations, including the choice of cloth and the number of patients treated.
When using fabric masks, they should be treated like disposables and not reused without proper sterilization. Washing them in hot water can deactivate the SARS virus.
What Risks Are Associated with Mask Usage?
It's essential to conserve masks for healthcare workers during the pandemic's initial stages. Mask usage can inadvertently lead to more face-touching, which may increase virus transmission. Thus, hand hygiene before and after adjusting a mask is crucial.
If a mask becomes wet, it could facilitate viral transfer to the face. However, the overall exposure risk while wearing a mask remains lower than without one.
Proper disposal or sterilization of used masks is critical, and hospitals are currently exploring ways to reuse them safely.
Should You Wear a Mask?
While masks can provide partial protection against COVID-19, the most effective strategy remains social distancing. For those living with sick family members or those re-entering society, wearing a mask—whether homemade or not—can be beneficial.
Unfortunately, there is a shortage of disposable masks, and hoarding them poses a risk to healthcare workers who require them most. If you have excess masks or the ability to make more, consider donating them to those at greater risk.
Should Everyone Wear a Mask?
Currently, the availability of masks doesn’t permit a mandate for everyone to wear them. However, fabric masks could serve as an alternative, yet further testing is necessary before official recommendations can be made.
As the situation evolves, it is crucial to shift the narrative from mask scarcity to the positive impacts they can have on public health. Protecting our healthcare workers with available masks, including homemade ones, is paramount.
Moreover, encouraging widespread mask usage can help mitigate transmission from asymptomatic carriers. The pandemic may persist longer than anticipated, making it vital to ramp up mask production and innovation.
Next Steps
For those interested in contributing to mask production, here are some resources:
- A simple fabric mask pattern from Deaconess Hospital using two layers of fabric.
- A contoured mask pattern for a better fit.
- Using a nylon stocking over a cloth mask to improve filtration efficiency.
- A visual comparison of fabric filtration efficiency relative to surgical masks.
- A DIY tutorial for creating disposable masks from basic materials.
- Methods to enhance the filtration efficiency of surgical masks.
By working together to create and distribute masks, we can better protect ourselves and those most vulnerable in our communities.