The Underlying Issues: Nonprofits and Systemic Change for a Better Future
Written on
Understanding the Nonprofit Landscape
Upon starting my first professional role after college, I opted to join a nonprofit organization. My motivation stemmed from a desire to contribute positively to society. Although I found my daily responsibilities somewhat tedious, I felt my efforts were aimed at helping others. Fast forward four years, and my enthusiasm has dwindled considerably.
My nonprofit focuses on assisting students in grades K-4 who struggle with literacy. Throughout my experience, I have come to understand that the challenges surrounding literacy are far more complex than simply some children finding reading easier than others.
The Roots of Reading Difficulties
The primary issue can be traced back to a singular figure: Lucy Caulkins. In the 1990s, she championed the “whole language approach” to reading instruction, which emphasized fostering a love for storytelling and providing literacy-rich environments. This method encouraged children to infer words from pictures and contextual clues rather than focusing on the mechanics of reading. Despite numerous studies debunking its effectiveness, Caulkins' curriculum has remained entrenched in teacher training programs and elementary schools nationwide. Consequently, we now face a reality where two-thirds of fourth graders in America struggle with proficient reading.
Even with evidence supporting structured literacy—teaching children phonetics and blending sounds—many schools continue to implement Caulkins' methods. This raises questions about declining academic performance in higher grades and the increasing reliance on visual content in social media. A significant portion of today’s youth simply cannot read effectively.
Historical Inequities in Literacy Access
The second, more intricate reason for widespread literacy challenges lies in centuries of systemic racism. This issue can be traced back to the 1500s when European colonizers began enslaving African people in the Americas. For over four centuries, Black Americans faced systematic denial of basic human rights, including access to education. Laws were enacted in numerous Southern states to prevent enslaved individuals from acquiring reading and writing skills, fearing that literacy could lead to insurrection.
Even after the 1865 Emancipation Proclamation, which was intended to free enslaved individuals, Black Americans continued to face barriers to quality education. The educational opportunities available to Black children were vastly inferior compared to those accessible to white students, despite the promises of equality following the landmark Plessy v. Ferguson case.
By the 1930s, while more Black students attended public schools, they encountered smaller facilities and underpaid teachers. The disparity in resources was stark, with school boards allocating nearly three times more funding per white student than for Black students.
The residual effects of Jim Crow laws, redlining, and ongoing discrimination are still felt today. Various marginalized groups, including Latino and Native American students, continue to encounter significant educational inequities, denying them the skills and knowledge necessary for upward mobility.
Addressing the Core Issues
What puzzles me is the persistent focus on temporary solutions, such as providing supplementary literacy support to struggling students in their later years, instead of addressing the foundational causes of these issues. Why do we invest millions in environmental clean-up efforts while neglecting to eliminate single-use plastics? Why do we provide job training and emergency supplies to the homeless without tackling the root causes of homelessness, such as exorbitant rents and insufficient wages?
If a significant portion of our greenhouse gas emissions stems from transportation, why aren’t we prioritizing walkable communities or regulating private jet travel? Why treat symptoms when the underlying problem is a systemic issue?
I believe in the inherent goodness of humanity and the importance of caring for one another and our planet. It baffles me that some individuals choose to amass wealth while many struggle to meet their basic needs, such as food and shelter.
While I acknowledge the valuable role of nonprofits in our society, it's essential to recognize that they often serve as temporary solutions. When we understand the root causes of societal issues, we must hold those responsible accountable. For instance, individuals with substantial wealth, like Jeff Bezos, have the capacity to address pressing global crises—such as hunger, extreme poverty, and educational disparities—while still maintaining their billionaire status. At what point does inaction become morally indefensible? When does a failure to act, despite the means to do so, render someone a villain?
In conclusion, while nonprofits are undoubtedly making a positive impact, they can only serve as a temporary fix. We must focus on preventing problems before they arise.
Chapter 1: The Role of Nonprofits in Society
The current landscape of nonprofits plays a crucial role in addressing various social issues, yet they often provide only temporary relief.
Section 1.1: Literacy Challenges
Our educational system faces significant challenges in literacy, largely due to outdated teaching methods and systemic inequalities.
Subsection 1.1.1: The Impact of Teaching Methods
Section 1.2: Systemic Racism and Education
The historical context of systemic racism has led to ongoing disparities in educational access and quality for marginalized communities.
Chapter 2: The Need for Systemic Change
In this chapter, we will explore the importance of addressing the root causes of societal issues rather than relying on temporary fixes.
The first video titled "Defund the Police Non-Profit Founder Caught In OUTRAGEOUS Lie" explores the challenges faced by nonprofits in addressing systemic issues.
The second video "SIDEMEN CHARITY MATCH 2023 [OFFICIAL STREAM]" highlights the efforts made by various organizations to raise awareness and funds for critical social causes.