Mechanism #1: The Rewarded Behavior Effect

Rewards serve as significant motivators, forming the core of many loyalty programs. Various academic studies indicate that customers tend to increase their purchases after receiving rewards, a phenomenon known as the rewarded behavior effect.

Why do rewards have such a strong impact? They activate the brain's dopamine system, which functions as a reward center. When individuals receive rewards, dopamine is released, resulting in a pleasurable sensation that encourages repeated behaviors that lead to those rewards.

Leveraging the Rewarded Behavior Effect

To effectively harness the rewarded behavior effect, consider the following:

1. Redemption Matters: Customers must redeem rewards to feel genuinely rewarded. If they never claim their rewards, they likely won't experience the motivating "rush" associated with them, which is crucial for engagement.
2. Anticipation is Key: Interestingly, the dopamine response is often strongest when individuals are anticipating a reward. This period, prior to actual redemption, is particularly motivating. Research indicates a "redemption momentum" phenomenon where merely deciding to redeem rewards increases the likelihood of additional purchases.
3. Combine Reward Types: While rewards drive behavior, an overemphasis on monetary rewards can lead to overly transactional relationships. Incorporating experiential, non-monetary rewards can foster a deeper connection with customers.

Mechanism #2: Point Pressure

The second mechanism, point pressure, has an intriguing background. The goal gradient theory suggests that animals, including humans, exert more effort as they near a goal—akin to how mice speed up as they approach cheese.

In loyalty programs, as customers near a reward or tier threshold, their motivation to make purchases or engage in other behaviors to earn points increases.

A classic experiment in a coffee shop demonstrated the point pressure effect. Customers who received a loyalty card that allowed them to earn stamps for free coffee purchases accelerated their buying frequency by 21% as they approached filling their card.

Leveraging Point Pressure

To utilize point pressure in your loyalty program, consider these strategies:

1. Implement an Earning Mechanism: Establish a points system that creates clear goals for members. This is essential for generating point pressure. Members should also have an easy way to track their progress toward rewards.
2. Capitalize on Cross-Selling Opportunities: As customers approach a reward, they become more focused on earning points. This is an ideal time for cross-selling or upselling products, so remind them of their proximity to goals.
3. Create Endowed Progress: Providing new members with bonus points or stamps can help them feel closer to their goals, enhancing motivation.

Mechanism #3: Elevated Status

Humans have a natural inclination towards achieving higher status compared to others, a need that can be particularly pronounced in societies with a strong hierarchy.

Airlines exemplify this understanding of status by offering premium tiers in their frequent flyer programs, often providing exclusive perks to their most valued customers.

Leveraging Elevated Status

To effectively implement elevated status in your loyalty program, consider the following:

1. Multi-Tier Structure: A tiered program design can significantly enhance sales and profits.
2. Meaningful Status Labels: The names of your tiers matter. Using labels that suggest status, such as silver, gold, or premier, can enhance the perception of exclusivity.
3. Manage Tier Size: Ensure that the exclusivity of your upper tiers is preserved. If too many members hold a premium status, it diminishes its value.
4. Pair Non-Monetary Benefits: While monetary rewards are often associated with status, non-monetary benefits can appeal to status-conscious customers and foster a sense of gratitude.
5. Address Potential Downsides: While tiers can make valuable customers feel special, they can also alienate non-premium members. Clear qualification rules and proactive management can mitigate these issues.

A great deal can be learned from the intricate psychology underlying loyalty programs. We hope these three mechanisms offer valuable insights for enhancing your loyalty strategy. Stay tuned for Part 2, where we will explore three additional psychological levers: sense of community, habit, and switching costs.

Want more helpful insights on customer loyalty? Follow us on Medium or connect with us on LinkedIn for further thought leadership on loyalty strategies.