Exploring Our Fascination with Infinite Progress: A Deep Dive
Written on
Chapter 1: The Infinite Concept in Modern Culture
Oswald Spengler, in his seminal work The Decline of the West, posits that our culture is profoundly shaped by a belief in the infinite, a notion he argues is entirely alien to Classical thought. This belief, he suggests, permeates our cultural fabric, especially in how we perceive time. Unlike many past civilizations, we view history as linear and believe in the inevitability of progress, a mindset that may obscure the reality of our impending challenges.
In Volume 1 of his work, Spengler emphasizes that mathematics is not a singular entity evolving from ancient times to the present but consists of multiple, distinct systems. Each mathematical framework is as incompatible with one another as Newtonian physics is with quantum mechanics:
"There is not, and cannot be, number as such. There are several number-worlds as there are several Cultures. We find an Indian, an Arabian, a Classical, a Western type of mathematical thought and, corresponding with each, a type of number — each type fundamentally peculiar and unique, an expression of a specific world-feeling, a symbol having a specific validity which is even capable of scientific definition, a principle of ordering the Become which reflects the central essence of one and only one soul, viz., the soul of that particular Culture."
The 'core essence' of our contemporary culture is rooted in the concept of infinity, which stands in stark contrast to the Greco-Roman emphasis on the immediate:
In the Classical world, the foundation of every creative act was the organization of the “become,” as it was observable, quantifiable, and definable. Conversely, the Western Gothic sensibility embodies an unrestrained, ambitious spirit, characterized by the idea of unbounded, imperceptible space. The notion of an infinite universe, which we accept as a given, is entirely absent from the Classical mindset.
Section 1.1: The Interplay of Infinity and Cultural Progress
A natural extension of the infinite concept is the belief in cultural advancement — historically referred to as the ‘perfectibility of man.’ This notion is exemplified in physicist David Deutsch's The Beginning of Infinity, which asserts that, through 'good explanations' (such as scientific inquiry), progress can be limitless:
"Old ways of thought, which did not seek good explanations, permitted no process such as science for correcting errors and misconceptions. Improvements happened so rarely that most people never experienced one. Ideas were static for long periods. Being bad explanations, even the best of them typically had little reach and were therefore brittle and unreliable beyond, and often within, their traditional applications."
Deutsch argues that the emergence of science, and the Enlightenment more broadly, marked the transition from static, localized ideas to a dynamic period characterized by rapid knowledge creation with expanding influence. Many ponder the sustainability of this progress. Is it inherently limited, or is this the onset of infinity — suggesting that these methods possess boundless potential for generating further knowledge?
Subsection 1.1.1: A New Dawn or a Looming Crisis?
Deutsch affirms the latter. Unlike Spengler, he contends that the failure of earlier civilizations stemmed from their static nature and an inability to generate knowledge swiftly enough to avert crises. Yet, Deutsch acknowledges that the challenge lies not in predictable issues but in those that are unforeseen. A paradigm shift is essential, akin to the revolutionary changes described by Thomas Kuhn in The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.
There are already discussions surrounding a crisis in science, particularly in our grasp of quantum mechanics. Spengler suggests that the ancient Greeks would perceive our mathematics as an elaborate display of skill rather than mathematics itself. It’s plausible that future paradigm shifts may also render our current understanding of mathematics unrecognizable.
Chapter 2: The Infinite in Action
In the video titled "To Infinity and Beyond," explore how the concept of infinity influences various fields, from mathematics to philosophy, and its implications on modern thought.
The second video, "Every 'To Infinity And Beyond' Line From 1995 to 2022," takes a look at the evolution of this iconic phrase in popular culture and its relevance in discussions about infinite possibilities and progress.