Creating a Just Society Through Mutual Aid and Solidarity
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Mutual Aid
How are human needs addressed in a just society? Today, we acknowledge that numerous needs remain unmet due to a system that prioritizes wealth accumulation for a few over addressing the needs of the many. There's an enduring belief that society is made up of isolated individuals where only the strongest can thrive.
The notion of "Survival of the Fittest," often misinterpreted from Charles Darwin's theories, suggests that only the strongest prevail. However, while Darwin observed the natural world during his extensive voyages on the HMS Beagle, others, such as Pëtr Kropotkin, offered a different perspective. Kropotkin’s studies in Siberia highlighted the importance of mutual aid within nature, which we will explore further.
Next, we will differentiate mutual aid from charity and examine various examples, including the Black Panthers, the Amish community, and Little Free Libraries.
Kropotkin's Insights on Mutual Aid
Pëtr Kropotkin, a scientist, historian, and revolutionary, led a remarkable life. Coming from Russian aristocracy, he could have pursued a prestigious military career but instead envisioned a world devoid of violence and oppressive governance.
His explorations of nature significantly shaped his political views. During his research in Siberia, Kropotkin encountered a stark contrast to the competitive survivalism that was widely accepted. Contrary to expectations, he found numerous instances of collaboration and mutualism within animal communities, leading him to conclude that cooperative behaviors were crucial for adaptation. For instance, animals would huddle together for warmth during cold nights.
Kropotkin also witnessed similar dynamics in human societies. In remote peasant villages, he observed that individuals worked together voluntarily, without coercion from any authority. This led him to rethink the concept of "natural selection," emphasizing the significance of cooperation over individual competition. His influential work, "Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution," encapsulates these ideas.
From nobleman to exile and revolutionary, Kropotkin’s life was filled with adventure. After escaping imprisonment due to his beliefs, he spent many years eluding Russian authorities while sharing his insights with others.
Mutual Aid vs. Charity
So, what exactly is mutual aid? It represents a form of solidarity that stands in stark contrast to charity. Solidarity involves organizing as a collective toward a common goal, with decisions made through consensus rather than imposed from above.
In contrast, charity often manifests as a one-time, transactional act that fails to address the underlying issues causing the need. Engaging in mutual aid fosters long-term relationships that empower communities to challenge the systems that perpetuate inequality. Mutual aid is about reciprocity among equals, whereas charity tends to be hierarchical, relying on the discretionary generosity of wealthy benefactors. This approach often provides only temporary relief, leaving many needs unaddressed.
Through mutual aid, individuals actively resist a system that creates scarcity and neglect. Solidarity offers an alternative to the notion that people should struggle alone.
Examples of Mutual Aid in Action
What does mutual aid look like in practice? Its forms vary based on community needs and local volunteers. For instance, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and activist Mariame Kaba developed a valuable resource called "Mutual Aid 101" in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, aiming to help communities meet urgent needs.
Throughout history, mutual aid has been particularly prevalent among marginalized populations. These groups recognize their interconnected struggles and form networks to support one another. It can be as straightforward as pooling resources for community benefit.
The Black Panther Party
The Black Panther Party (BPP) exemplifies mutual aid through its commitment to serving the Black community in various ways, despite being labeled as extremists by many. One notable initiative was the Free Breakfast Program, which began in 1969. Understanding that learning is challenging on an empty stomach, the Panthers mobilized community resources to ensure children received nutritious meals before school, motivated by studies linking breakfast to improved academic performance.
Despite government hostility, including surveillance and harassment under the COINTELPRO program, the Panthers remained dedicated to uplifting their community. Their legacy demonstrates the power of mutual aid in combating systemic oppression.
The Amish Community
The Amish practice mutual aid through events known as frolics, where community members come together to socialize and work collaboratively. These gatherings exemplify the spirit of mutual assistance, as seen during barn-raisings, where neighbors unite to construct a barn or community building in a matter of days. The deep sense of care for one another drives their solidarity, reflecting their cultural values.
Free Stores
Another innovative approach to mutual aid is the concept of free stores, where individuals can take what they need without any payment. This idea, initially popularized by the Diggers in San Francisco during the 1960s, exemplifies an alternative to the conventional economic model. These stores operate on trust, allowing people to exchange goods without the barriers typically associated with commerce.
The first video, Defend Mutual Aid: Pushing back against attempts to criminalize solidarity, explores the importance of mutual aid and its role in fostering community support.
Tool Libraries
Tool libraries offer another form of mutual aid, enabling communities to share tools and resources. For instance, Second Harvest of Nashville operates a Tool Share program, allowing neighbors to pool their tools for collective benefit. This approach not only saves money and space but also fosters social interactions and collaboration.
Little Free Libraries
Little Free Libraries are small, community-driven book exchanges that promote literacy and access to literature. Founded in 2012, this nonprofit movement encourages people to share books in their neighborhoods, creating a culture of giving and receiving.
Free Clinics
Access to healthcare remains a significant challenge, often hindered by financial barriers. Free medical clinics serve as a vital resource, organizing volunteer professionals to provide care to those in need. Organizations like Remote Area Medical travel to underserved areas, offering essential services without requiring identification or payment.
Community Fridges
Community fridges address food insecurity, particularly in areas designated as food deserts. These fridges, stocked by community members, provide fresh food to those who may otherwise struggle to access it. They promote dignity and choice, allowing individuals to obtain food without the stigma associated with begging.
Community Gardens
Community gardens represent yet another form of mutual aid, where individuals collaborate to grow food, foster relationships, and share their harvests. These gardens not only provide nourishment but also enhance community spirit and resilience.
Summation
In conclusion, voluntary associations and mutual aid networks flourish today. Rather than competing for limited resources, communities thrive when they come together to address genuine human needs. Although oppressive systems have existed for generations, a brighter future is achievable through collective action.
We have seen how the Black Panther Party challenged systemic racism to uplift their community, and the Amish continue to strengthen their bonds through shared labor. You, too, can engage in mutual aid! Identify unmet needs in your community and mobilize the right individuals and resources to effect change. By working together, we can build a more equitable world for everyone.
JM Heatherly (He/They) is a writer, gardener, hospitality professional, and musician from Tennessee.
The second video, "Mutual Aid" is a People's Movement (an ASA 2020 Freedom Course), delves into the principles of mutual aid and its significance in fostering community solidarity.